How to Avoid Car Insurance Scams

Learn about potential car insurance scams and what you can do to avoid them right here through Savvy’s handy guide.

Written by 
Savvy Editorial Team
Savvy's content writing team are professionals with a wide and diverse range of industry experience and topic knowledge. We write across a broad spectrum of finance-related topics to provide our readers with informative resources to help them learn more about a certain area or enable them to decide on which product is best for their needs with careful comparison. Meet the team behind the operation here. Visit our authors page to meet Savvy's expert writing team, committed to delivering informative and engaging content to help you make informed financial decisions.
Our authors
, updated on February 15th, 2024       

Fact checked

At Savvy, we are committed to providing accurate information. Our content undergoes a rigorous process of fact-checking before it is published. Learn more about our editorial policy.

Car Insurance Banner - Unhappy couple checking financial records after falling victim to a car insurance scam.

Are you concerned about falling victim to car insurance scams in Australia? It's essential to know how to protect yourself and make informed choices when purchasing car insurance. At Savvy, we understand the importance of safeguarding your interests and providing reliable information to help you avoid scams.

In this comprehensive guide, we'll share valuable insights and practical tips on how to spot and steer clear of car insurance scams, ensuring that you make the right decisions for your insurance needs. Learn about the steps you can take to avoid potential scams right here with us today.

What are common signs of car insurance scams in Australia and how can I avoid them?

Car insurance scams can be financially devastating and leave victims in a difficult situation. To protect yourself from falling victim to a scam, it's crucial to be aware of common signs and take preventive measures, which is especially the case if you’re a young or inexperienced driver. Here are some red flags to watch out for and tips to avoid car insurance scams:

  • Unsolicited offers: be cautious of unsolicited calls, emails, or text messages offering unbelievably low insurance premiums or claiming that you've won a free policy. When buying car insurance, it’s important to note that legitimate insurers typically don't engage in cold calling or unsolicited offers.
  • Pressure tactics: scammers may use high-pressure tactics to rush you into making immediate decisions without proper research or comparison. Take your time, do thorough research, and make informed decisions based on reputable sources.
  • Unlicenced or unknown insurers: verify the credibility of the insurance company before purchasing a policy. Check if they are licenced and regulated by relevant authorities such as the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) or the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA).
  • Fake websites and documentation: be cautious of websites that mimic legitimate insurance companies or offer policies without proper documentation. Look for secure websites with HTTPS and verify the company's details before sharing any personal or financial information.
  • Advance payment requests: exercise caution if the insurer demands upfront payments or requests payment through unconventional methods such as wire transfers or gift cards. Legitimate insurers typically provide various payment options and do not ask for large sums upfront.

To avoid falling victim to a scam on your car insurance, it's essential to research and compare different insurers, read customer reviews and seek recommendations from trusted sources. Be sceptical of deals that sound too good to be true and never hesitate to ask questions or seek professional advice before committing to a policy.

By staying vigilant and taking these precautions, you can significantly reduce the risk of falling victim to fraud in Australia. Also, check your state or territory government or insurance body's website to see if they have any resources to help you avoid and report scams, such as the Motor Accident Insurance Commission in Queensland.

If I'm in an accident, how can I avoid being scammed by the other driver?

If you find yourself in an accident, it's important to be vigilant to avoid being scammed by the other driver. Unfortunately, there are certain tactics that scammers may employ to take advantage of the situation. Here are some tips to protect yourself:

  • Exaggerated vehicle damage: scammers may attempt to inflate the extent of the vehicle damage to claim a higher insurance payout. To protect yourself, document the accident scene by taking photos or videos that clearly show the damage to both vehicles. If possible, gather witness statements or contact information to support your case. It's also important to report the accident to your insurance provider promptly and provide them with accurate information.
  • Pretending to be injured: some scammers may pretend to be injured to file fraudulent personal injury claims. To avoid falling victim to this scam, be cautious of individuals who immediately claim to be injured without any visible signs or who insist on receiving cash compensation at the scene. Call emergency services to report the accident and wait for the police to arrive. If the other driver claims to be injured, encourage them to seek medical attention and exchange insurance information through proper channels.
  • Deliberate crashes made to look accidental: in some cases, scammers may intentionally cause a crash and make it appear as if it was an accident. They may abruptly brake, swerve into your lane or perform other dangerous manoeuvres. To protect yourself, maintain a safe following distance, be aware of your surroundings and drive defensively. If you suspect that the other driver intentionally caused the accident, gather as much evidence as possible, such as witness statements, photos or dashcam footage. Report the incident to the police and your insurance provider.

Remember, it's crucial to always exchange insurance information with the other driver involved in the accident and report the incident to the police. Notify your insurance provider promptly and provide them with accurate and detailed information about the accident.

What types of hire car insurance scams should I look for?

It's important to be aware of frauds related to hire cars to protect yourself and ensure a safe and legitimate car hire experience. Some scams which may take place with hire car insurance include:

  • Hidden fees: some car rental companies may advertise low daily rates but add numerous hidden charges when you pick up the vehicle. Before finalising the booking, carefully read the terms and conditions, including any additional charges for insurance, fuel, mileage or late returns. Ask for a detailed breakdown of costs to avoid surprises.
  • Damage disputes: scammers may attempt to hold you liable for pre-existing damages to the rental car when returning it. Before driving off, thoroughly inspect the vehicle, document any existing damage and inform the rental company. Take photos or videos of the car's condition to have evidence in case of disputes.
  • Unlicensed rental operators: be cautious of individuals or companies offering rental cars without the necessary licenses and permits. Verify the legitimacy of the rental company, check their licences and ask for identification and rental agreements. Reputable rental operators will provide proper documentation and maintain their vehicles in good condition. Also, if you’re unsure of their legitimacy, you may be able to double-check with the other driver to see if they represent them (should the other driver’s insurance supply the vehicle).
  • Phony insurance coverage: some scammers may offer additional insurance coverage at the time of rental, claiming it's necessary to avoid liability. However, they may provide fake or invalid insurance, leaving you unprotected in case of accidents or damages. Always verify the authenticity of the insurance coverage and confirm it with the rental company or your car insurance provider.

To protect yourself from hire car scams, it's important to book rentals through your current insurer (if you have access to one) or other reputable companies, read the terms and conditions carefully and inspect the vehicle thoroughly before accepting it. Report any suspicious or fraudulent activities to the appropriate authorities.

Helpful guides on car insurance

Car Insurance Banner - Couple driving in an open-top car, happy about receiving a no-claim bonus on their car insurance.

No-Claim Bonus in Car Insurance

Find out more about no-claim bonuses and how they can benefit your car insurance policy right here with Savvy. Looking...

Car Insurance Banner - A young couple sitting in their car checking their car insurance policy on a tablet.

How to Check Car Insurance

Learn about how to check your CTP insurance and other types of car insurance with Savvy. In Australia, car insurance...

Compare car insurance policies with Compare the Market

Savvy is partnered with Compare the Market to help you compare a range of car insurance policies from a panel of trusted providers.

Explore car insurance options by make

Select your car make and find out how much it may cost to insure, read helpful guides and compare quotes.


Savvy (ABN 78 660 493 194, ACR 541 339) provides readers with a variety of car insurance policies to compare. Savvy earns a commission from our partnered insurers each time a customer buys a car insurance policy via our website. All purchases are conducted via our partners’ websites. The integrity of our comparison service is unaffected by our partnerships with those businesses and our effort remains to bring further brands that do not already use our comparison service onboard.

Savvy’s comparison service includes selected products from a panel of trusted insurers and does not compare all products in the market. Any advice presented above or on other pages is general in nature and doesn’t consider your personal or business objectives, needs or finances. It’s always important to consider whether advice is suitable for you before purchasing an insurance policy. We always recommend readers to consult the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) of different policies before purchasing your car insurance.

Car Insurance Banner - Unhappy couple checking financial records after falling victim to a car insurance scam.

We'd love to chat, how can we help?

By clicking "Submit", you agree to be contacted by a Savvy Agency Owner and to receive communications from Savvy which you can unsubscribe from at any time. Read our Privacy Policy.